It was okay. Good for layering too as it seems to tame and balance stronger perfumes.

I keep catching whiffs of it throughout the day and thinking "wow, something smells good", and then realising it's the perfume. I usually hate sweet and fruity scents, but this is just sharp and smooth enough that I bought a large bottle after using up the sample size.

Sour raspberry juice and a mild woody drydown, the fruitiness lasted longer than I expected being a bright fruity note. Loving it and must try the other spaces of it next

Missed the mark with this one. It is exactly what it says it is. Imagine a fruit juice with no sugar and no creamy ness.

Give the people what they want. Creamy, sweet and fruit notes. This is too tart.

Smells so clean and fresh. I love this fragrance, and keep it in my purse for everyday use!

Did not expect the perfume to be that strong and long lasting. Definitely one of my favourites and will always be part of my perfume library from now onwards

I’d have to look, but I don’t think I placed an order for juice+, Quite sure I have not. I did just order and received the duo milk and gold and received a sample free of Velvet. I’m sure it’s exceptional and will be sampling it soon 😊

Excellent fragrance

I wanted it to smell like the expressive but last longer. The expressive stays a juicy, fruity and vibrant smell but doesn’t last long. The Bold version smells good, but turns more to a rose, patchouli on my skin. It lasts about 3 hours on skin and 5-6 on clothes. The only samples for Juice were the expressive, and Juice + didn’t come in my full discovery set, only another Juice expressive sample. I don’t dislike it.

This has a mature sweetness and warm scent. Definitely long lasting scent.

Totally gorgeous. Soft, sweet skin, totally mesmerising. Ethereal, and so classy. I’ve already bought a second bottle!

So many compliments, I adore it!

Absolutely love this scent. Soft, clean, skin like scent. Beautiful all the way.

The perfect scent for any occasion. I am so picky about scents and this one is absolutely my new signature scent

Warm, woody, amber-y, sensual, aromatic, softly sweet, sophisticated, cozy, comforting, and with a soft spicy freshness. I find the vanilla, amber, juniper, and sandalwood to be the most prominent notes. I do get a bit of a spicy freshness from the juniper, especially in the opening. As it dries down it becomes more warm and cozy. It has a really golden feel from the warmth of the molten amber that swirls throughout the rich vanilla and woody Sandalwood.

This vanilla perfume is pure magic! It opens with a creamy, sweet vanilla that feels warm and inviting without being too sugary. As it dries down, hints of amber and soft musk add depth, making it perfect for day or night.

It lingers beautifully on my skin, and I’ve lost count of how many compliments I’ve received. Feminine, confident, and irresistible—this scent is a must-have for any vanilla lover!

This is one of my favorite fragrances! Smells fabulous and is long lasting!!

Gold has been thee best fragrance I have ever used. I have had continued compliments on it from day one; from little old ladies to my 11-year-old granddaughter. This fragrance transcends all generations. One spray on the back of my neck last all day. In all my more than 50 years of using/trying new scents, this has been my favorite by far.

I've always loved Gold and was distraught when it was no longer available for purchase. I'm definitely not an expert and I like what I like. Soo happy that Commodity is back and even more pleased with this version of Gold!!!

This accent is a compliment magnet. I will never be without this delectable fragrance. This is my third bottle. I'm obsessed. Sweet woody vanilla with hints of saffron. Layer this with Milk+ and thank me later. Absolutely delicious.

my favorite scent ive ever smelled. better than fresh baked cookies or flowers. people stop me in public and ask what i’m wearing… this is my 3rd purchase of the gold+ and the consistency of the smell from 1st bottle to 3rd is unparalleled and perfect.

I absolutely love this fragrance, especially layered with Milk Expressive. You knocked it out of the ballpark with those two. Absolutely wonderful!

Unglaubliches Produkt! Der Duft hält sehr lange und ist einzigartig. Super für jede Gelegenheit

If want something with a bit more kick than paper personal. This is it. Feel like it has more staying power too. Especially on clothes. Funny thing is I wasn’t too keen on the expressive but now I’m contemplating it with how much I like this.

I received this sample via scentbird and was my introductory scent to Commodity. It is light, not too sweet, cozy and warm. A great everyday not too overpowering scent that makes you truly wanna cuddle up and have a movie night or, dare I say, book session ;) g

This is my absolute favorite fragrance for everyday, any situation wear. It smells like clean, fresh woods, and just a touch of citrus. It's complex and delightful.

I had my first commodity perfume from Sephora, while living in New York. Back in Estonia (Europe), I really started to miss these perfumes. I tried different perfumes that would consists musk, amber, sandalwood, but nothing was really like it. Happy I can order it through net also in Europe now :)

Sehr schöner, würziger und doch leichter Duft, der sehr lange anhält. Ich benutze ihn gerne als Finish über Book Expressive! Herrlich …

I love Book. I think I smell like an expensive forest. It’s so different from anything else I own. A new favorite

Very pleased, glad I got to try it out first

Love this so much. Cozy, tea scent. Clean and crisp. Getting the bold version next!

So Good. Will have to get the full version later

Love everything about this scent! Book is scrumptious! Just one spray makes me smile from ear to ear. It's a posh scent, it's cozy, it's sophisticated, it makes me feel fabulously glam!

A beautiful, intense scent that stays on my skin for a really long time. This fregrance is perfect for autumn, winter and evenings. Love them!

I am an avid book lover and honestly this is perfect this makes me feel warm and exotic it doesn’t give me migraines at all and it sits perfectly through the day I’ve gotten so many compliments!

I got the discovery kit since it gives you the discount off the full bottle and I fell in love with Book+!! It's not harsh while still being a strong smell and lasts for hours! I've gotten so many compliments on it already and plan on repurchasing when I get low (which might be soon with how often I wear it)

Had to special order this from the US because it’s not available in Sephora Canada. This is the greatest scent ever. Found it in a discovery kit and became obsessed. Packaging was a little annoying, but I guess it’s meant to be ripped off and not slid off!

nice

Velvet is just in time for Fall. I love each level and it smells so good. All of the discovery expressions set has a s subtle scent that is soft and not so overpowering. Will Invest in a bottle to get me through Fall/Winter!

My second bottle and I’m obsessed, head turning scent, beautiful design and affordable!

This is the best perfume ever, I love when my wife wears it

Fragrance that lasts all day, delivering subtle notes that appear to change throughout the day

Lovely perfume

Don’t like it at all .

a touch smokey with a deep but reserved sweetness that comes out for the rest of the day.

It’s like nothing I’ve ever had before and at first took ome getting used too but when the small sits it is absolutely amazing exactly as described I love ittttty

My favorite Commodity scent. Perfect for winter.

I can’t stop smelling this and how it changes all day long. So different and mesmerizing, absolutely scrumptious…

You guys haven’t sent it out it hasn’t been picked up by the courier and I haven’t heard back from you in days after confirming the shipping address

I originally purchased a Bold Discovery set through Ipsy, and fell in love with several Commodity scents, but especially Velvet+. The fragrance wraps you in a blanket of musky rose, amber, and light patchouli and doesnt let go. This is not a playful scent, it's seriously seductive.

*

L’odeur est celle que je recherchais depuis longtemps

It’s my new favorite go-to scent! I’ve gotten so many compliments on it already, love how fresh it is, and how it changes subtly throughout the day.

I wanted something that was earthy but also sweet, and this fragrance absolutely nails it. I love that it lasts so long but stays close to my body. I feel like it's something that I can enjoy and anyone I get close enough to for a hug, but it's not filling up a whole room and forcing itself on everyone in the area. Just a perfect balance in every way.

I love laying moss with milk. A beautiful fresh + warm and toasty combination.

Was für ein traumhaft zitrischer Duft. Dieser riecht so schön nach Bergamotte und ist bei mir lang anhaltend.

My daughter got this for Christmas and she loves it! Not an over-powering scent, light and clean smell. . . I like it too!

I love this scent so much. I first tried it as a scent bird item and I’ve been in love since. It’s both classic and modern, crisp and musky. The Velvet sample I got is now a second favorite.

I have been wearing Moss for probably 10 years and at least once a week a get a compliment on the scent. I will never wear anything else.

I love that this is complex enough to stay interesting throughout the day, but has familiar notes that reliably work well on me.

I bought a sample set and Moss stood out to me. It’s the perfect fragrance for me and I choose it over others every day.

I feel like I've become a perfume snob, and Moss+ is my new go-to when I'm looking for a green / grass / light floral scent. I love most Commodity scents (especially Velvet and Paper), but Moss+ is by far the one I get the most compliments on.

Practically perfect!! Love this stuff

I personally use the Moss perfume, but my husband loves the Moss + version! Together we smell amazing lol!! Loveeee this one on him 😍

love this scent. i hate sweet notes in colognes for men, just a personal preference. this is one of the few that don't have that. the scent is very natural and green, very masculine. i get a lot of compliments on it, and i love the way it dries down and lingers all day.

A lovely, slightly masculine scent that really lasts

Es lo mejor para la oficina

I received a 10ml of Paper- in a subscription box, and I was hooked! To me, it takes the smell of fresh, warm paper at the copier and makes it a romantic and sexy fragrance. I get so many compliments!

I really enjoy the brightness of this fragrance. Unfortunately I meant to order Paper +, so I was ultimately a bit disappointed, but I’m happy to know all the scents are long wearing and beautiful.

I love how Paper interacts with my skin and lingers throughout the day. I’m also impressed how Commodity values their customers. Fragrances are enjoyed an favs among our family!

I love paper . It’s perfect with my ph balance . I love it, it’s warm & makes me want to give hugs .

I bought a set to introduce myself with Commodity perfume. It was a pleasant surprise because I either loved or liked them, there was no dislike. My husband liked the Paper and my son liked the book and my favorite was Milk-, so I bought all of them!

This is literally my favorite perfume scent I've ever had, but it only lasts for like thirty minutes. You have to keep reapplying. So the scent is five stars, the price for how quickly I'll go through the bottle, two stars.

I absolutely adore this fragrance. A crisp yet soft musk. Sandalwood but with a cooler "finish" than what normally associates with sandalwood due to the cedarwood. Iso E Super is a note that either works with your body chemistry or it does not - and I am a lucky one! You yourself will become "nose blind" to the scent (due to the Iso E Super) on and off during the day but others will always be able to detect it on you.

This is the best skin scent I’ve tried so far, I love it!

I got a discovery set and fell in love with Paper. I wore it until the little sample was gone and then ordered a big bottle because I just couldn't live without it! This big bottle just smells like alcohol. It's not the same at all! I'm so frustrated and sad. I keep trying it every few days hoping for a change but no luck. Feels like'the one that got away' and I'm at a loss on how to rate this. 5 stars for the sample and 1 for the bottle I guess equals a 3? Ugghh... :(

my boyfriend loves this scent just as much as I do!! It's so fresh yet sophisticated, definitely a signature scent!!❤️️

the preferences I clicked on refer to his personal taste!

Grateful to find this at a decent price!

I received a sample of Paper+ through a monthly service about a year ago, and ever since I've been obsessed with it. I've got a few bottles of other fragrances that are just about out, and I knew that this would be my next purchase. Hands down my daily scent, whether in the office or an evening out.

Incroyable, je l’ai découvert avec le kit exploration et je l’adore !

this is the nicest perfume i have tried in a long time, lovely scent and long lasting

This is definitely the most lactonic of the milk trilogy, in the best possible way. The initial spray is all cold, clean milk, then as it settles the marshmallow comes in and sweetens things up. As time goes on the musk becomes more prominent, with just a light underlying woodiness. It’s such a cozy scent, perfect for autumn and winter.

I'm not a fan of sweet or gourmand scents, except for some of the bubblegum tuberose and some woody, but with sweet undertones scents, like this one. For me this is a perfect cold weather cozy scent for when you are wrapped in a blanket or a soft thick sweater.

very calm and sweet! I love it !

Smelled good, very fresh.

Delicious fragrance that has now become my signature fragrance. Love it

Love this cozy scent It's appropriate for the office but also a fun night out To me it leans more fall and winter but it could definitely be all Yr round. It's gourmand but has plenty if other touches so you don't feel like you are wearing food. Love it!

Yummy, comforting and utterly delicious!

This is the most delicious, cozy scent on the planet. It’s perfect for the cold days of winter sitting by the fireplace!

It was everything I was expecting to be !

I was not optimistic when I first sprayed it on. I had tried so many other scents. Only Chanel No. 5 had impressed me. But the instant I breathed in Milk+ Bold, I was in love. My scent forever.

Kind of scent I’ve never smelled.

But I love it very much!!!

Long lasting and I got great compliments about the scent 👍🏻

Ordered for my Son for Christmas! Very pleased with scent!

Milk+ is the absolute best!! Amazing, wear this everyday with compliments. Delicious!